Home Improvement Decisions

DIY vs Hire a Pro vs Move Calculator

Compare DIY, full-pro install, hybrid, and just-move-instead for 20 of the most common renovation projects — with real Cost-vs-Value ROI, time estimates, and total-cost math.

Most renovation cost guides give you a national-average number and stop there. That's not actually a decision — it's a price tag. The real question is: DIY, pay a pro, do a hybrid, or skip the whole project and move instead? Each of those has a different total cost, time commitment, risk profile, and resale impact. We built a page for each of the 20 most common projects (kitchen, bath, deck, roof, HVAC, solar, basement, ADU, paint, flooring, windows, siding) with all four options compared side-by-side. Numbers come from Remodeling Magazine's Cost vs Value report, HomeAdvisor's true-cost surveys, and the National Association of Realtors' Remodeling Impact study. Save scenarios, share a prefilled URL with your spouse, and read 900+ words of write-up that's specific to your project — not a generic ROI table.

  • 20 most common renovation projects covered
  • 4 options per project: DIY, pro, hybrid, move
  • Real Cost-vs-Value ROI on every page
  • Time-to-complete estimates for DIY and pro
  • Scenarios, prefilled URLs, print to PDF
  • Cited sources on every page
Kitchen — minor remodel
Kitchen — minor remodel: DIY runs ~$9,500 in 3–6 weeks, pro install $27,500 in 4–6 weeks. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 85.7%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Kitchen — major remodel
Kitchen — major remodel: DIY runs ~$28,000 in 10–16 wk, pro install $78,000 in 10–14 wk. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 49.5%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Bathroom — full remodel
Bathroom — full remodel: DIY runs ~$7,800 in 3–5 weeks, pro install $25,400 in 3–4 weeks. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 66.7%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Primary suite addition
Primary suite addition: DIY runs ~$65,000 in 4–6 mo, pro install $165,000 in 4–6 mo. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 24%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Deck addition (wood)
Deck addition (wood): DIY runs ~$5,800 in 1–2 weeks, pro install $17,600 in 1–2 weeks. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 82.9%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Garage door replacement
Garage door replacement: DIY runs ~$1,100 in 1–2 days, pro install $4,500 in 1 day. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 194.1%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Siding — fiber cement
Siding — fiber cement: DIY runs ~$11,000 in 3–4 weeks, pro install $22,100 in 1–2 weeks. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 88.4%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Siding — vinyl
Siding — vinyl: DIY runs ~$7,800 in 2–3 weeks, pro install $17,400 in 1 week. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 80.2%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Windows — vinyl replacement
Windows — vinyl replacement: DIY runs ~$8,500 in 2–3 weeks, pro install $19,400 in 1 week. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 61.4%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Windows — wood replacement
Windows — wood replacement: DIY runs ~$14,000 in 3–4 weeks, pro install $26,100 in 1–2 weeks. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 60.5%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Roof — asphalt shingle
Roof — asphalt shingle: DIY runs ~$11,500 in 1 week, pro install $24,500 in 2–3 days. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 56.9%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Roof — metal
Roof — metal: DIY runs ~$28,000 in 2 weeks, pro install $49,000 in 1 week. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 48%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Basement finishing
Basement finishing: DIY runs ~$18,500 in 8–14 weeks, pro install $57,000 in 8–12 weeks. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 70%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
ADU (in-law unit) build
ADU (in-law unit) build: DIY runs ~$110,000 in 8–12 mo, pro install $245,000 in 8–12 mo. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 65%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
HVAC system replacement
HVAC system replacement: DIY runs ~$4,800 in 3–5 days, pro install $11,200 in 1–2 days. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 35%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Solar panel install
Solar panel install: DIY runs ~$13,500 in 1–2 weeks, pro install $26,500 in 1 week. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 48%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Inground pool
Inground pool: DIY runs ~$38,000 in 6–10 weeks, pro install $67,000 in 6–8 weeks. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 25%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Flooring — hardwood
Flooring — hardwood: DIY runs ~$4,800 in 2–3 weeks, pro install $11,500 in 1 week. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 70%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Flooring — luxury vinyl plank
Flooring — luxury vinyl plank: DIY runs ~$2,400 in 1 week, pro install $6,900 in 3–5 days. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 60%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25
Exterior paint
Exterior paint: DIY runs ~$1,800 in 2 weeks, pro install $7,200 in 1 week. National Cost-vs-Value ROI: 152%.
4 options · updated 2026-05-25